(617) 397-5663

Field Notes

Cost-Plus vs. Fixed Price: Picking the Contract That Fits the Job

A homeowner asks which kind of contract you use. Most builders answer with the one they always use, and that is usually how the argument in month seven gets started.

The contract type decides who pays when the job turns out different from the drawings. Every custom home turns out different from the drawings somewhere. So the choice is really about where the surprise lands, and whether the paper said so before anyone started digging.

There are four common shapes. Each one works on some jobs and fails on others, and the failures are predictable.

Fixed price and the lump sum contract

A fixed-price contract, also called a lump sum contract, sets one number for a defined scope. The builder takes on the cost risk. If framing labor runs over, that is the builder's problem. If it comes in under, the difference is the builder's margin.

The owner sees one number and a payment schedule. They do not see your costs, and they are not entitled to.

What makes it work is definition. The drawing set, the specification and the selections all have to be named in the contract, by date, so the price is attached to something fixed. Anything not yet decided goes in as an allowance, written as one. Changes after signing get a written change order before the changed work starts. I laid out what that form needs in the change order template.

Where it goes wrong: the drawings were not finished when the number was set. The builder priced what the set showed, the owner assumed what the set implied, and the gap between those two gets fought over one change order at a time.

Cost-plus contracts in construction

Under a cost-plus contract the owner pays the actual cost of the work plus the builder's fee. The risk moves toward the owner. If the job costs more, they pay more.

The fee comes in two forms, and they behave differently.

Cost plus a percentage. The fee is a share of whatever the cost turns out to be. It is simple to write. It also means the builder earns more when the job costs more, which every owner eventually notices, usually around the time the tile allowance doubles.

Cost plus a fixed fee. The fee is a set dollar figure, agreed at signing, for managing the job. Costs go up, the fee stays put. Owners tend to trust this one more because nobody profits from an overrun. The fee may need its own rule for when the scope grows enough that the original figure no longer covers the work.

The owner sees everything under cost-plus: invoices, sub payments, material receipts. That is the selling point, and it is only true if the builder can actually produce those records on demand.

GMP: cost-plus with a ceiling

A guaranteed maximum price contract is cost-plus with a ceiling on it. The owner pays actual cost plus fee, up to the maximum. Above the ceiling, the builder pays.

The part that needs writing down is what happens below the ceiling. If the job comes in under the GMP, the savings may go back to the owner in full, get split by an agreed share, or stay with the builder. Any of the three can be fair if the contract names it. Unnamed, the owner will assume the first one while the builder priced for the second or third.

A GMP also needs the same definition as a fixed price. The ceiling is only meaningful against a named scope. Change the scope and the maximum changes with it, by change order.

Time and materials

Time and materials pays labor at an hourly rate and materials at cost, usually with a markup, and there is no fixed scope. It fits small work, repairs, and the investigation phase of a renovation where nobody knows what is behind the wall yet.

On a whole custom home it rarely serves either side. The owner has no idea what the total will be, and the builder has no scope to point to when the owner asks why.

Fixed price vs. cost-plus, side by side

Fixed price / lump sumCost-plus, % feeCost-plus, fixed feeGMPTime and materials
Who carries cost riskBuilderOwnerOwner, fee cappedShared, builder above the ceilingOwner
What the owner seesOne price, a draw scheduleEvery costEvery costEvery cost, plus the ceilingHours and receipts
What must be defined firstDrawings, spec, selections, by dateWhat counts as cost, the fee basisWhat counts as cost, what moves the feeAll of the above, plus the savings splitRates and markup
Where it goes wrongUnfinished drawings priced as finishedFee grows with the overrunScope creep past the feeSavings nobody agreed onNo total until the end

Which one fits which custom-home job

The drawings are complete. Permit set done, spec written, most selections made. Fixed price fits. You can count what you are building, and the owner gets the certainty they are paying for.

The drawings are not complete. Design is still moving, or the owner wants to start site work while the interior is decided. Cost-plus with a fixed fee, or a GMP once the set firms up, is the honest choice. Pricing a moving design as a lump sum is how a builder ends up either padding the number or eating the difference.

Existing-conditions renovation. Nobody knows what the framing looks like behind the plaster. A fixed price works for the parts you can see. The concealed conditions need their own clause: priced and signed before the work proceeds once they are opened up. Some builders run the demolition and investigation on time and materials, then fix the price for the rest.

The owner wants open books. Some owners simply want to see where the money goes. Give them cost-plus, and be sure you can deliver what that promises.

Allowances under each contract

An allowance is a placeholder for something not yet chosen: the tile, the fixtures, the appliance package. How it behaves depends on the contract.

Under a fixed price, the allowance is a line inside the lump sum. When the owner picks a tile that costs more, the difference is reconciled by change order. When they pick less, the credit goes back to them. The contract should say both.

Under cost-plus, allowances matter less on paper because every cost is passed through anyway. They still matter to the owner, because an allowance is what they budgeted against. Keep them listed, even when the contract does not strictly require them.

The damage allowances do to a bid when they are set low to win it is its own subject. I went through it in you did not lose on price.

Open books need a real cost report

Owners who ask for cost-plus are buying visibility. What they usually get is a stack of invoices once a month and a total at the bottom.

A real cost report goes further. It shows each line of the budget, what has been committed, what has been spent, and what is left, against the same lines every month. The owner can read it without calling you. If you cannot produce that from the way your books are kept today, cost-plus is going to cost you trust even when your numbers are right.

What a cost-plus contract has to define

Before anyone signs, the contract should settle four things.

  1. What counts as cost. Field labor, yes. Your office manager's time, the pickup truck, small tools, insurance, permit runs? Each one is either a cost or covered by the fee. Write the list.
  2. The fee basis. Percentage or fixed, what it is calculated on, and what changes it.
  3. Audit rights. The owner's right to see the records, how far back, and how often.
  4. A not-to-exceed, if there is one. If you are offering a ceiling, it is a GMP, and the savings rule belongs in the same paragraph.

A fixed-price contract needs its own short list: the contract documents by date, the allowances as allowances, the change-order rule, and a draw schedule that adds up to the contract sum. The construction agreement in the Bid Room suite carries all four, and the pillar on construction contracts walks through the rest of the paperwork between yes and the first day on site.

One caveat. I do not practice law, and the choice between these belongs in front of an attorney licensed where you build.

Choose the contract when you price the job

The contract type belongs in the conversation before the number does. How you bid depends on it: a lump sum needs a take-off from your own drawings, a cost-plus job needs a budget the owner can track against. The take-off half of that is in how to bid construction jobs.

If you are not sure which contract you are actually using, send it over. On the document suite page you can upload the agreement from your last job. It comes back rebuilt in your brand next to the other two documents, with a list of what it leaves open, starting with whether the pricing method is defined at all. Free. The rest of the pricing is printed on the rate card, and the paperwork has its slot in the marketing plan, under Systems.

Book a working session